Collecting Antique .22 Caliber

Antique Revolvers

(Sidebar for firearm factoid: Both President William McKinley and Senator Robert Kennedy were assassinated with Iver Johnson revolvers.)

Now, the bullets weren't made "in or before 1898, " but that straight-forward standard doesn't apply to the ammo. Instead, due to an overly-literal reading of the statute, we end up with this test, as articulated by the Seventh Circuit:

Bullets are "ammunition" if they are "designed for use in any firearm." 18 U.S.C. § 921(a)(17)([A]) (emphasis added). If these bullets had been designed exclusively for use in [defendant's antique] revolver, they would not be "ammunition" because by definition this antique revolver is not a "firearm." On the other hand, if the bullets were designed for use, not just in this antique revolver, but in other guns manufactured after 1898, then it would appear, given the literal language of the definition, that they are "ammunition" because they would be designed for any firearm.

Lets break down this complicated test.

  • It's not a "firearm" if the gun was made in 1898 or earlier;
  • If the bullet fits in a gun made after 1898, it fits in a "firearm, " and is therefore "ammunition."
  • If a felon has either a "firearm" or "ammunition, " he violates the GCA.

Of course, they could just take a shortcut, go to Google, and discover that the Remington and Winchester ammunition found in his gun is almost certainly not black powder. The .32 S&W black powder rounds have been obsolete since 1909, and as you might expect, finding ammo is pretty much impossible outside of custom shops.

Shortcuts aside, the court took a different route and held that because he was seeking an exemption from the statute, it was his burden to prove, as an affirmative defense, that the ammo flunked the Seventh Circuit's test. The same burden applies to claims of antique firearms. He failed to meet that burden at trial.

It wasn't all bad news, for Royal however. The Fourth Circuit also used the Supreme Court's recent holding to overturn a sentence enhancement under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA), which led to his fifteen-year sentence. He'll face a maximum of ten years on remand.

Share this article

Related Posts

Buck Knives Collectors Edition
Buck Knives Collectors Edition
Collectible Case Pocket Knives
Collectible Case Pocket Knives

Latest Posts
Cool Ninja Swords
Cool Ninja Swords
A functional Ninja sword for under $50…
Best Spyderco steel
Best Spyderco…
The world of steel is as fluid as molten…
Case Pocket Knives Engraved
Case Pocket Knives…
Case Pocket Knives make Great Gifts!…
Old Guns.Net
Old Guns.Net
We frequently refer to NRA conditions…
Spyderco Tenacious Plain Edge Knife
Spyderco Tenacious…
When choosing the best pocket knife for…
Featured posts
  • Buck Knives Collectors Edition
  • Franklin Mint collectibles Knives
  • Collectible Case Pocket Knives
  • Case Collectors Club Knives
  • Collector hunting Knives
  • Collective Knives
  • John Wayne collectibles Knives
  • Collecting Case Knives
  • Case collector Knives
Copyright © 2020 l All rights reserved.